Jerry Blake (Terry O Quinn, Lost) is a man obsessed with having the perfect American Dream life, including the house with the white picket fence in the suburbs, an adoring wife, and loving children. He believes he has found it when he marries Susan Maine and becomes the stepfather to her 16-year-old daughter, Stephanie. But Stephanie gets an uneasy feeling when she is around Jerry with his Father Knows Best attitude. She can see that there is a darker side behind his cheerful exterior. Could she just be going through the typical teenager rebellion against her new stepfather, or is he actually the same man who brutally murdered his family just one year earlier?